Saturday, August 18, 2012

Retroactive Reductions Sought in Crack Penalties

WASHINGTON — In a proposal that could allow as many as 5,500 federal inmates to apply for reduced prison terms, the Obama administration on Wednesday backed retroactively lightening some sentences for past crack cocaine convictions.

Testifying before the United States Sentencing Commission, Attorney General Eric H. Holder Jr. cited the Fair Sentencing Act, a 2010 law that increased the volume of crack cocaine necessary to result in a mandatory minimum prison term.

The panel, which advises federal judges on how much prison time they should hand down for particular offenses, revised its crack cocaine sentencing guidelines last fall in response to the 2010 law. Mr. Holder said that it should make those changes retroactive for certain offenders, allowing them to seek a reduction in their prison terms.

“Because of the Fair Sentencing Act, our nation is now closer to fulfilling its fundamental, and founding, promise of equal treatment under law,” Mr. Holder said. “But I am here today because I believe — and the administration’s viewpoint is — that we have more to do.”

At the same time, citing public safety concerns, Mr. Holder urged the commission to make an exception for inmates who had significant criminal histories or who had possessed or used a gun at the time of their drug offense. Because such inmates could be more dangerous, he argued, they should not be eligible to seek reduced sentences.

The administration’s position prompted some political criticism. The chairman of the House Judiciary Committee, Representative Lamar Smith, Republican of Texas, issued a statement on Wednesday accusing the administration of “supporting the release of dangerous drug dealers,” saying the proposal “shows that they are more concerned with well-being of criminals than with the safety of our communities.”

But Julie Stewart, the president of Families Against Mandatory Minimums, a group that advocates for judicial discretion in sentencing decisions, contended that the commission should make its crack cocaine guidelines retroactive without any exceptions because criminal histories and any gun possession were already factored into sentences under a separate part of the guidelines.

“I think it’s political,” Ms. Stewart said of the Obama administration’s stance. Interviewed by phone, she characterized the Justice Department’s position as “splitting the baby.”

Congress established the sentencing commission in an effort to make federal prison sentences more uniform. In 2005, the Supreme Court ruled that its guidelines could not be binding, but many judges still follow them.

Several sitting federal judges are members of the commission, which is expected to decide by November whether to make the new guidelines retroactive.

The commission recently released a study showing that about 12,040 federal inmates would be eligible to apply to a judge for a reduction, without the carve-out suggested by Mr. Holder. The study said the inmates would potentially be eligible to have their sentences cut by an average of 37 months.

The study showed that about 513 of those inmates were convicted in one of the four federal districts in the State of New York. The vast majority of the overall group consists of black men, and their average age is 36, the study said.

The commission has also released a study of what happened to inmates who won early release after 2007, when it made retroactive a related set of changes to its crack cocaine guidelines. The study found no statistically significant disparity in the recidivism rate of that group when compared with a control group.

The panel’s deliberations are the latest chapter in a long-running, racially charged debate over severe mandatory minimum penalties for crack cocaine offenses enacted by Congress during the crack epidemic in the 1980s, amid a crime wave fueled by addicts and rival drug traffickers.

Under those laws, a drug dealer selling crack cocaine was subject to the same sentence as one selling 100 times as much powder cocaine. Crack cocaine was disproportionately prevalent in impoverished black communities, while powder cocaine was disproportionately favored by more affluent white users.

Mr. Holder had long argued that the crack-powder sentencing disparity was an injustice, and lobbied Congress earlier in his tenure as attorney general to enact the Fair Sentencing Act, which reduced the disparity to 18-to-1 by raising the volumes of crack that result in mandatory minimum sentence levels.

But Congress did not make the mandatory minimum changes retroactive. As a result, the commission is considering a proposal that would allow judges to remove prison time in excess of the old statutory minimum sentences, but such inmates would still not be eligible for a reduction to the new minimum sentences established by the 2010 law.

For example, under the old law, a person convicted of selling 75 grams of crack cocaine faced a sentence of 10 years to life in prison, while today he would instead face 5 to 20 years in prison. If the guidelines become retroactive, such an offender who had been sentenced to 12 years in prison several years ago could ask a judge to reduce his sentence to 10 years, the old statutory minimum term.


View the original article here

Friday, August 3, 2012

Two FIFA Officials Are Suspended; Blatter Is Cleared

But in a hearing Sunday, an ethics panel found no wrongdoing by the FIFA president Sepp Blatter, clearing him to run unopposed for a fourth term. The vote is scheduled for Wednesday.

Suspended on Sunday were Mohamed Bin Hammam of Qatar, who sought to challenge Blatter for the FIFA presidency, and Jack Warner of Trinidad and Tobago, a longtime power broker in the soccer federation.

Bin Hammam and Warner were accused of offering cash gifts of $40,000 apiece to about two dozen officials representing soccer federations in the Caribbean at a meeting held in Trinidad on May 10 and May 11. In return for the cash, the officials were expected to vote for Bin Hammam as FIFA president.

Accusations against the two officials were made by Chuck Blazer, an American who is also on the FIFA executive committee and had been a longtime ally of Warner’s.

Bin Hammam and Warner could eventually be expelled from FIFA if a further inquiry finds them guilty of the bribery charges. Warner has previously been accused of offering to sell his vote for the 2018 World Cup, which he denied.

“We are satisfied that there is a case to be answered,” Petrus Damaseb, deputy chairman of FIFA’s executive committee, told reporters at a news conference in Zurich, where FIFA is based.

Bim Hammam, who withdrew his presidential bid on Saturday, has claimed that Blatter knew about the cash offers and approved them, perhaps as a kind of development fund to be paid to the Caribbean nations. Blatter was cleared of wrongdoing Sunday.

Still, Blatter’s credibility has suffered greatly, given that his 13-year presidency has faced a number of corruption crises within FIFA. Eight of the 24 members of FIFA’s executive committee have been accused of selling or offering to sell their votes for the 2018 and 2022 World Cups, which were awarded last fall to Russia and Qatar, respectively.

And there is a chance that more tawdry revelations could undermine Blatter’s presidency ahead of Wednesday’s vote.

In cryptic remarks, Warner, who is also president of soccer’s North American, Central American and Caribbean region, known as Concacaf, said that a “football tsunami” would strike FIFA in the coming days “that will shock you.”

The situation is so chaotic within FIFA that Blatter has not ruled out a re-vote to award the 2022 World Cup. The United States finished second to Qatar in a vote that was compromised by charges of vote-trading and bribery.

Sunil Gulati, president of the United States soccer federation, has been tight-lipped in comments about the FIFA scandals, wanting to keep the United States in the best standing possible in case there is a re-vote for the World Cup.

He would not comment on a potential re-vote in an interview last week, referring instead to recent remarks to Sports Illustrated, in which Gulati said, “Any of us who participate as bidders or anyone watching this from the outside knows that the process needs to be reviewed and reformed.”

Even with a stirring 3-1 victory by Barcelona over Manchester United on Saturday in the European Champions League final, a match that displayed why soccer is known as the beautiful game, the sport finds itself covered by dark clouds of corruption.

Franz Beckenbauer, the former German great who is soon to retire from FIFA’s executive committee, told the BBC on Sunday that the crises were “a disaster for football.”

Hugh Robertson, the British sports minister, has called on FIFA to suspend its presidential election, telling reporters, “I think the process is fast descending into farce.”


View the original article here